Hey there everyone, I'm back with another blog post, this time after I started writing an email reply about how work shirts have changed over time. Admittedly, this is a bit of a rough sketch attempt I'll make below, but I want to go into some detail to explain how styles changed (and didn't) in various eras.
I suppose I could go way, way back regarding "work shirts" (like, ancient Greece or China, or the Ice Age) but let's stick with the more semi-modern era, starting with the turn of the century.
The turn of the century is an interesting time for workwear; along with the 1910s, there's actually a great deal we don't know about it, or at least less attention has been paid to it. That's because unlike the 1940s, 1930s, and even 1920s, there are fewer vintage pieces that have survived. Instead, a lot of what we know from this time period cones from catalogs, ads, photographs, and the relatively fewer existing vintage pieces.
Let's take things back a little to 1897 with Sears Roebuck & Co.:
And a selection of shirts from Sears Roebuck in 1902:
And Montgomery Ward, also in 1902:
As you can see, catalogs from this time didn't always offer the most detailed illustrations, but we can glean some info from them and their descriptions, such as the fact that fabrics including chambray, sateen, wool, moleskin, and even Stifel’s indigo-dyed fabrics were being used. Shirts were essentially always pullovers, and you'd occasionally find esoteric styles and detailing, such as very large front plackets, shield fronts, lace-ups, etc.
Something happened in 1899-1900 though in terms of shirt design:
This patent for a double front, double back, double elbow work shirt, filed by one S. Elbaum, would influence shirts that would make up the basis for my first product, the Heracles Work Shirt.
Although in an earlier form, the scalloped back yoke’s double fabric layer, here with drop shoulders and as seemingly one piece that connects to the double front, would be a huge inspiration, as can be seen in the Heracles:
At the turn of the century, work shirts mostly featured "chinstraps", a modern term for the extension neck band.
Extension neck bands on the Heracles and Bull Dog work shirts.
The purpose of the extension neck band was to keep the top button from pulling or sagging, to give the wearer a neater appearance when buttoning the shirt up, and to keep out the elements.
Shirts at this point were single-needle or double-needle stitched, labels were often cotton and printed (not woven tags, which were more common in dress, sport, and the hybrid dress-work shirt), back yokes tended to be very high and thin. Some of the construction quality from this time period could appear crude when viewing such items up close by today’s standards, but sewing methods and machines would improve rapidly.
Something interesting happened in 1904, in the Wyman, Partridge & Co. Wholesale Catalog out of Minneapolis: a new kind of front scalloped yoke work shirt appeared:
This is the earliest example I’ve seen yet of a scalloped double-front shirt, and something we won’t see again until 1912. Again, this would lead directly to the Heracles shirt.
Work shirts in started to change more at some point nearing 1910. In 1910 proper, we find the following pages from that year's Sears Roebuck catalog, including the birth of the mail-order business' now-famous line of Hercules clothing (at this point just a work shirt sub-brand):
Two years later, in the 1912 Sears Roebuck catalog, shirt designs remained similar, except for a curious new entry:
This is the first documented example I can find of a scalloped back yoke and scalloped shoulder yoke combo in a work shirt. In this same year, Reliance Mfg. Co. of Chicago, founded by Milton F. Goodman, would patent a very similar design.
Here is the 1910s Reliance version on an undated box it would have come in; although we don't know the date for this, it carries a patent date of Dec. 24, 1912; this box is likely from the mid to late 1910s:
Image courtesy of e-Workers.
And we find the same images, crudely reproduced, on a newspaper ad clipping from 1914:
And then this 1914 ad from Reliance:
Image courtesy of Yahoo! Auctions
This us the basis for our Heracles shirt, which differs in that it incorporates more 1930s elements:
Here we have a most interesting piece in the 1916 Montgomery Ward catalog:
The front yokes go under the collar, yes, but the back! It's almost a freedom sleeve at first glance, but it's because it's a triple layer of fabric, with the two top layers extending all the way down to the elbow.
Finally, we have the Sears Roebuck catalog of 1918:
In 1919, Reliance ran this ad for its various shirt sub-brands, from Milton F. Goodman to the new Big Yank brand, Black Beauty black sateen shirts, Honor Bright shirts for boys, and Old Faithful, the rarest and most difficult to find:
Another fun shirt from the period, note the shawl collar shirt below. These types of convertible collar shirts were also known as sport shirts and sold as short-sleeve items with sleeves that went down to the elbow:
With each passing decade we have more info to glean about work shirts. In the 1920s, the biggest single development is the introduction of the "coat style" shirt. This is what we think of today as a regular, button-front shirt, as opposed to a pullover. Of course, it wasn't a wholesale change overnight, so we still find catalogs that will offer pullovers in this decade, especially early on.
Here's Montgomery Ward in 1920:
The shirt on the left is coat style, whereas the shirt on the right is a pullover. Notice how the left-hand shirt still has a cutout in one pocket for a pocket watch.
Montgomery Ward continued down this path again in 1922:
And some other examples from the same catalog, this time with different, unique styling, including another type of ventilation hole:
Here's a vintage example of a deadstock, 1920s Brave Man chambray shirt by way of eBay; note the high, thin back yoke that was common in this era:
And another chambray pullover from the 1920s that appears to be a children’s sized shirt:
I can’t seem to find the image source for this one anymore, let me know who to credit.
Another very similar Peerless child’s pullover chambray work shirt from Overall Days:
And a shirt box for a 1920s Roomy Richard chambray pullover, image courtesy of Speedway Sendai:
Wintertime calls for a heavier shirt, like this wool one from Pendleton that sold over at Cocky Crew Store; here we also see a woven tag, something that was gaining ground in the 1920s:
The following MWS Work Shirt in indigo warp and weft chambray is from an ad set that MWS ran from 1920-1921:
And more MWS ads from a magazine clipping in my personal collection:
Stifel’s polka dot was a popular fabric for work shirts at this point too, especially worn railroad men. Here’s a polka dot pullover in a photo from my personal collection:
I reproduced this shirt with wabash dot stripe fabric as the Bulldog work shirt:
In the 1920s, J.C. Penney heavily promoted their new Pay Day work shirts which were quietly rebranded as Big Mac work shirts, (possibly the real inspiration for the famous burger’s name?), leaving the Pay Day name for their overalls line:
Their answer to the Milton F. Goodman shirt was the Compass shirt:
Reliance would continue its advertising in the 1920s, here’s an ad from 1922 for the Milton F. Goodman shirt:
Here's a 1920s example of the Milton F. Goodman shirt in black sateen:
At the bottom of the ad, Reliance also mentions its Black Beauty shirt; I have two magazine clipping ads for this shirt in my personal collection, both undated but clearly from the 1920-25 time frame; here they are:
Reliance went on an advertising tear in 1923-24 so that timeframe provided lots of great illustrations, like these:
I’ve only seen two examples of a surviving Reliance Black Beauty shirts, here’s what’s essentially a dead stock one posted by Cocky Crew Store:
Here are some more Reliance ads from the same time frame.
Here are photographic examples from the 1920s of workers wearing black sateen shirts, courtesy of David Patrick of Briar Vintage:
And some from A.G. Silvers:
Here's two more glimpses of the MFG shirt again, one from 1922 and the second from an undated ad likely from the 1920s; note that the pocket shape has changed in the second image:
And another full-page that I have in my personal collection:
The Milton F. Goodman shirt was made in blue chambray, black and other colors of sateen, and khaki, that we know of.
Here are some photos of the few existing examples of the MFG shirt, in blue chambray and khaki jean:
Pretty soon we'd see another patent for a ventilated yoke shirt design that was filed in 1928-29 by John W. Champion:
We’re now reaching the end of the decade; in 1928-29, we can find this triple-stitching, scalloped-yoked no-vent holes work shirt from Montgomery Ward: